My UPD8
You need to login before you download the free activities. You can register here.
- The Centre for Science Education
- The Association for Science Education
- Partners
- Part of ASE online
Choosing trainers
Type: Activity
Learning Strategy: Data work
Topic: Pressure & moments
Scottish scientists asked the question Are expensive trainers worth the money? This activity presents some results of their just-published research, and gets students to analyse them.
After doing a ranking exercise, students consider what makes a trainer comfortable, and learn that good cushioning reduces pressure. They then measure the pressure their own feet exert before analysing and evaluating data to compare the cushioning effects of cheap and expensive trainers: are expensive trainers worth the money?
11-16 How Science Works:
Communication skills
3c Present information, develop an argument and draw a conclusion, using scientific, technical and mathematical language, conventions and symbols and ICT tools.
Published: 31st October 2007
Reviews & Comments: 10
Learning objectives
Students will learn:
• that pressure can vary depending on the area to which force is applied
• to analyse and interpret data
• to draw conclusions from data
Try the activity
- Choosing trainers activity
Downloaded: 5576 times - Choosing trainers teachers notes
Downloaded: 2829 times
You will need Acrobat Reader installed to open the activity sheets.
Curriculum link
11 – 14 (KS3)QCA Unit 9L Pressure and moments
• the effect of a force depends on the area to which it is applied
• using the quantitative relationship between force, area and pressure
• practical applications of this relationship
GCSE specifications
AQA – Core
How science works
10.7 Using data to draw conclusions
21st Century Science – core
Ideas about science
1 Data and their limitations
Running the activity
Page 1 discusses what makes a good trainer, or rather what makes it a desirable item. Students rank 9 factors to consider when buying new trainers.
Page 2 sets the context and tasks for the rest of the activity.
Page 3 explains pressure and gives the relationship between force and the area to which it is applied. Students work out the pressure exerted by their feet in a simple class activity that involves measuring the area of the foot and their weight. This activity may be best done in groups with willing volunteers to avoid problems with students sensitive about their weight.
Pages 4 and 5 is the data analysis activity. Data from a recent study looking at whether expensive trainers are worth the money is presented in 4 bar charts. Students study the data to answer the question 'Do expensive trainers cushion best?' The data is actually rather inconclusive – the cushioning from brand to brand, within brands and in different parts of left and right feet varies hugely. The researchers themselves concluded that there is no simple link between cost and cushioning.
[Notes:
1. The data presented here has been adapted from the Venn diagrams produced by the researchers. The relative pressures given are very approximate.
2. The article Do you get value for money when you buy an expensive pair of running shoes? appears in the British Journal for Sports Medicine, published online 11 October 2007. It is available to subscribers or on payment of a fee.]
Web links
News links
- The Times Online
- They may cramp your style, but cheap trainers are fine for feet - article describing the research
- BUPA
- Choosing the right trainers
- Feet for Life
- More advice on choosing a sports shoe
Reviews & Comments
Write your online review to share your feedback and classroom tips with other teachers. How well does it work, how engaging is it, how did you use it, and how could it be improved?
year 8 data and evidence applied to every day
Mar 21st, 2013
my most able pupils found the task a challenge when looking at the data but all found the task motivating and interesting. (yr 8)
Reviewer: kathryn bye
Choosing trainers review
Aug 18th, 2011
This was brilliant and got everyone talking and even my most troublesome pupil was on task and engaged.
Reviewer: Karen Duxbury-Watkinson
Choosing trainers
Mar 18th, 2011
Dear Author of this activity.
This is a well designed activity and fun to do in the class.
on page 3 there is the calculations for pressure.
To convert the area of the foot from cm2 to m2 we need to divide by 10000 the sheet say 1000.
Also could you please clarify why we multiply by 0.5 when the note says "When you run the pressure is much bigger"
Do we calculate the pressure using the area of the ball of your foot? - for running?
Reviewer: Alpana Kelkar
Choosing Trainers
Jun 22nd, 2010
Did a slightly altered version of this activity with a low ability Year 10 group. They were all engaged - they loved the group discussion as to what was most important when selecting a pair of trainers! At first they struggled to understand why we were measuring pressure rather than mass, but then they got on with the activity. I challenged them to design a pair of trainers and highlight the design features for a bit of cross curricula box ticking!
Reviewer: Jo Christopher
Choosing trainers review
Feb 21st, 2010
This activity worked well with several groups of differing ability. The activity is easily extended to look at the pressure put on your feet while wearing different types of shoes. There is also the possibility of getting students to design a trainer themselves thinking about what materials they would use and why.
Reviewer: Rebecca Daw
Forensic Science
Sep 24th, 2008
This activity was well organised and the images were easy to read when printed for the students. The students (aged 17-18) enjoyed working out the force and pressure applied to different areas of their feet. The students did not realise they were doing mathematical calculations as the activity was more interesting. All students managed the calculations and could answer all the questions by reading the graphs. A very good activity enjoyed by all. No additional material was required for activity to work effectively.
Reviewer: Jennifer Innes
Choosing trainers
Jun 17th, 2008
An excellent acivity, very differentiated by outcome. My top set group got well into it.
Reviewer: Fred Hampson
Choosing trainers review
Jun 4th, 2008
Have not tried yet, just browsing!
Reviewer: John Saddler
Mistake?
Mar 7th, 2008
Is the conversion factor in the 'Finding Your Pressure' activity wrong? 1 square metre is 10,000 square centimetres so the area found in step B should be divided by 10,000, not 1,000.
Pedantic Bob strikes again!
Reviewer: Bob Kerrigan
Think 30
Jan 11th, 2008
A great activity for getting a particularly scary looking equation across to a difficult yr 11 group. They really engaged with it although I ended up with some factually correct but gruesome powerpoints.
Reviewer: Tracy Hill
200 lessons and assessments from as little as £4.95
Related Activities
Ideas about Science / Data collection & analysis
- Time raiders - death of a mummy
- Inside Easter Eggs
- When will women overtake men?
- False diamonds
- Bushtucker challenge
- Healthy Eating
- Riches from the Wind
- High Speed Risk
- Should we be worried about salt?
- Turkey
- Santa 2025
- Think 30 for a reason
- Winter Olympics
QCA / 9L Pressure & moments
- Sports clinic
- Leaning tower
- Javelin jeopardy
- Ellen's moments
- Plane as big as a school
- Winter Olympics
How Science Works / Interpreting data
- Pluto: a planet no more
- Hard Stuff
- Australian light bulb ban
- Fast car
- Earth 2
- Riches from the Wind
- Godzilla is real!
- Rats
Difficult & Dull / Pressure & Moments
Physics / Pressure & moments
Learning Strategy / Data work
- Bionic body
- Bushtucker challenge
- Santa 2025
- Winter Olympics
- Killer Flu
- Should we be worried about salt?
- Tsunami Warning
- When will women overtake men?
- MMR
- Inside Easter Eggs
- Einstein's time
- Riches from the Wind
- Shampoo claims - truth or lies?
- High Speed Risk
- Acid rain: Britain recovers?
- Think 30 for a reason
- Rats
- Global warming-do 'the facts' stand up?
- Pluto: a planet no more
- Turkey
- Australian light bulb ban
- So windy
- Earth 2
- Fast car
- Death of an angel
- Ban UV beds
- Antibiotic cockroaches