My UPD8
You need to login before you download the free activities. You can register here.
- The Centre for Science Education
- The Association for Science Education
- Partners
- Part of ASE online
Life for a life
Type: Activity
Learning Strategy: Case study
Topic: Reproduction
Genetic technology offers a lifeline to the parents of children with debilitating, incurable diseases. An injection of healthy cells might cure them. Embryo selection could give them a baby with matching tissues to provide these cells. Until now, this has been illegal in the UK. On 21st of July 2004 the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA) relaxed the rules. Should we be worried about the consequences? Are we on the slippery slope towards 'Designers babies'? The activity gets students to take on the role of the HFEA at the point where they were deciding whether or not to relax their rules. It is organised like a question time, with a panel of scientist, ethicist and legal expert contributing to the debate. The activity is adapted from the 'Genetic Futures' DNA 50th anniversary schools programme.
The activity was originally developed by The Centre for Science Education, Sheffield Hallam University. The Genetic Futures programme was sponsored by The Medical Research Council, The Royal Society, The Department for Education and Skills, NESTA, The Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council, The Department of Trade and Industry, The Department of Health (DH) and Bio-Rad Laboratories Ltd.
Published: 5th March 2005
Reviews & Comments: 25
Learning objectives
The activity promotes an understanding of ethical issues by encouraging students to explore the risks and benefits of embryo choice technology.
Try the activity
- Activity sheet
Downloaded: 11344 times - Teachers notes
Downloaded: 4811 times
You will need Acrobat Reader installed to open the activity sheets.
Curriculum link
The ethics of pre-implantation genetic testing.GCSE specifications
AQA Additional Science
Unit B2 Biology: 11.8 Which human characteristics show a simple pattern of inheritance?
• Make informed judgements about the economic, social and ethical issues concerning embryo screening that they have studied or from information that is presented to them.
Edexcel Core Science
Unit B1a Topic 2: Genes
• Consider the contemporary scientific theory of 'designer babies' and explain why today's scientists are finding so much opposition to this being publicly accepted.
Twenty First Century Core Science
Module B1 You and your genes: B1.3 How can and should genetic information be used? How can we use our knowledge of genes to prevent disease?
• Understand the implications of testing embryos for embryo selection (pre-implantation genetic diagnosis).
Running the activity
Starter activity: Project the top half of page 1, or display it on an OHP. This presents the dilemma faced by the parents of a child with a debilitating genetic disease. A quick vote can be used at this stage to gauge students' initial reactions to the problem.
Main Activity: The bottom half of page 1 introduces the main activity which is intended to provide the basis for a more considered judgment. The debate can be organised like a "Question Time", with volunteers acting as the panel of experts. To ensure an informed debate, the panel needs to be carefully chosen and briefed in advance. Researchers in Residence, Science Ambassadors, trainee teachers or older students could play a part. Page 2 can be printed to provide briefing cards for students taking on expert roles. The rest of the class can be split into small groups. Each group has to generate ethical, scientific and legal questions to put to the panel. Page 3 can be photocopied to provide a set of prompts to help with this. A question and answer session follows, with groups taking it in turns to pose their questions. Plenary: Students can discuss their response to the debate in small groups and write their individual decisions on the voting cards provided on page 4. The students' responses can then be compared with the HFEA's decision to relax the rules on embryo choice to allow a life for a life.
Web links
News links
- BBC Health News
- A news article written on the day the HFEA decision was announced. It summarises a range of reactions to the news.
- BioEthics Education Project.
- Accessible summaries of the techniques and issues.
- Centre for Bioethics and Human Dignity
- A thought-provoking article on the ethics of pre-implantation genetic diagnosis from the Centre for Bioethics and Human Dignity.
- genetics.com
- A fact sheet on pre-implantation genetic diagnosis.
Reviews & Comments
Write your online review to share your feedback and classroom tips with other teachers. How well does it work, how engaging is it, how did you use it, and how could it be improved?
Biology
Apr 23rd, 2015
very interesting activity which engaged the pupils well and promoted discussion
Reviewer: Hannah Grant
biology
Dec 2nd, 2012
Great!
Reviewer: tabi cotchin
new link
May 3rd, 2012
http://www.genetics.edu.au/Information/Genetics-Fact-Sheets
new link to fact sheets as old one does not work....trying this with a year 9 mixed-low ability group, who prefer talking than writing...will let you know how it worked
Reviewer: heather taylor
Embryo Screening
Mar 11th, 2012
A perfect case study that is just right to allow E grade students to be sucessful along side the A grade students.
I look forward to teaching this this week.
Reviewer: Amanda Anderson
Life for a life review
Oct 9th, 2011
Excellent activity
Reviewer: K B
replica watches
Jul 29th, 2011
In this modern and fashionable society, people are pursuing for [url=http://www.watchreplicasale.com]Replica Watches[/url] cool, unique, stylish and innovative. Whether it is [url=http://www.watchreplicasale.com]watch replica[/url] or fashion accessories all means a lot for modern society of today. Same is the case with trendy looking [url=http://www.watchreplicasale.com]replica watch[/url]. When these are [url=http://www.watchreplicasale.com]fake watches[/url], the excitement just gets doubled. Most chic looking [url=http://www.watchreplicasale.com/rolex-c-434.html]replica rolex[/url] are in fashion now. These are one of the favorite fashion accessories for men and women long time ago. If you have not yet tried [url=http://www.watchreplicasale.com/rolex-c-434.html]rolex replica[/url], it's time to own one and feel the difference it can make to your personality.
Reviewer: jiang tao
reproduction- gene technology
May 3rd, 2011
what a thought provoking lesson. Trying to get girls to form an opinion on an issue related to genetics. Good link up to 'my sister's keeper' jodie picoult.
Reviewer: brenda goodwill
Life for a life review
Nov 6th, 2010
My students enjoyed this activity , they where engaged right from the starter activity highly recommended
Reviewer: Helen Onyeaka
Science
Sep 4th, 2010
Raised a very interesting debate with my Top Set Yr 9's.
They're a highly moralistic lot and took the activity very seriously.
Good to find an activity that really made them think.
Reviewer: Simone Lively
Life for a life
Jun 21st, 2010
I made this more structured and used it with a year 8 and 9 group. It was the first time the year 8 group had done this style of lesson. I gave them a role to play so they could gather the different arguments between them and they bought into it really well. Giving them roles seemed to take away the fear of their opinions being wrong.
Reviewer: colin ANDERSON
Couldnt download the activity sheet
Mar 16th, 2010
I'm sure this is a great activity but the pdf wont download, it just keeps returning me to this page.
Looks like a great idea but shame I cant use it
Reviewer: Peter Banks
life for a life
Dec 17th, 2008
My year 9 group found the topic captivating. We had just completed the basics of inheritance & cloning and then put what they had learnt into practice.
This led on to another lesson where the class worked towards producing a documentary on the topic of embryo selection. Amazed how stimulated they were
Reviewer: Joanna Hinds
life for life
Jun 17th, 2008
Very topical, used with an A-level group.
Reviewer: kantha choudhury
Life for a life review
Oct 12th, 2007
Reviewer: Catherine Selva
Yr 11 and stem cells
Sep 21st, 2007
I used this activity with a top set triple science class in year 11 as a basis for a discussion on the use of stem cell research. They found it very engaging and it gave them a chance to really discuss the ethical issues before writng an editorial on the subject for homework.
Reviewer: Tamsin Morrell
life for a life
Jun 15th, 2007
Great activity, used with year 10 to teach you and your genes ethics part. Engaging, pupils had to try very hard to come to a conclusion. Most said that it was difficult to know whether it was right or not. An engaging activity!
Reviewer: Julia Magnall
Life for a Life June 2007
Jun 10th, 2007
I used this with a nice year 9 (post Sats ) group as lesson 3 of topic B1 (21st Century Science)
Having talked about how the "How Science Works" course would operate it was really nice to have such an activity to offer.
After the initial introduction we took a straw pole and had quite a few students who were unable to make a decision. By the end of the topic all students voted and were still talking about it as they left the room.
I printed out the supporting articles to have on hand and this worked well but I think it may work even better in an IT room where they could do their own research. This has been set as homework.
Highly recommend
Reviewer: Sharon Tharme
Life for a Life
Jan 28th, 2007
I used this with my year 11 class to cover topical issues in genetics. Students were very engaged and enthusiastic, and the materials impressed the RS teacher who was observing!
Reviewer: Zoe Spavold
Life for a Life
Jan 26th, 2007
Used this with year 10 classes looking at aspects of gene technology, and potential uses for genetic testing information. The class became very involved in discussing the 'moral' aspect of the work, a positive lesson all round.
The film 'GATTACA' was a good introduction to possible futres based on this sort of research.
Reviewer: Ian Spilsbury
Life for a life review
Nov 30th, 2006
Used with a difficult, and noisy, middle set Year 10 in connection with AQA Science work on Fertility. They need to hone up on their debating skills but the activity generated a lot of interest, excitment and a surprising outcome. We did a straw poll at the start of the lesson in which nearly all the class voted to create the new baby but this idea was modified radically by the end of the lesson, when we conducted a secret ballott.
Christine Wolfe
The Forest School
Reviewer: Christine Wolfe
Designer Babies
Nov 20th, 2006
Excelllent resources which engages the pupil with my year 10- Foundation class. Quite accesssible because there was not a lot of information from text to sieve through- Very Ideal.
Reviewer: patricia oremosu
Life for a life
May 23rd, 2006
I used this activity with year 11 classes. I informed the girls a few weeks in advance which gave the question time panel plenty of time to research their facts. On the day we had a very lively discussion. I will certainly use it again.
Reviewer: jane warwick
Life for a Life
Apr 14th, 2006
Excellent.
Top set year 7 loved this activity. They really got into the moral questions about "is it right" and "what would the created child think" -- made a lovely wall display of their thoughts too.
Highly reccommend
G
Reviewer: Glen Gilchrist
life for a life
Feb 18th, 2006
Great activity, useful for yr 7 (top set admittedly) through to yr 11 BD4 topic. An activity which is working towards the new KS4 curriculum. Interesting and relevant.
Reviewer: Alayna French
Life for a Life
Nov 29th, 2005
Used this with my Year 11 classes last term to cover the 'Bell Topic' on ethical issues in genetic engineering from the AQA syllabus. Pupils researched the issues and brought in articles - then we conducted the (heated!) debate. Brought the topic to life!
Fiona Paton - Olchfa School
Reviewer: Fiona Paton
200 lessons and assessments from as little as £4.95
Related Activities
Edexcel / B1a Genes
AQA / B2 Homeostasis & Genetics
How Science Works / Decisions & ethics
Hot Topics / Genetics
Biology / Reproduction
Biology / Inheritance of characteristics
Learning Strategy / Case study
- False diamonds
- Charge!
- Ellen's moments
- Deadly Dengue
- New deal for diabetics
- Art Attack
- Faulkes Telescope free courses
- Moon mission 2020
- Physics idol
- Solar roadways
- Sinking island
- Bird flu - can science save us?
- Ulcer bug breakthrough
- Bionic Vision
- Top Dog
- Here comes the sun
- Ban Wi-Fi?
- Is it terminal for Teflon?
- Is Glastonbury Sustainable?
- Cannabis
- test
- Sports clinic
- Leaning tower
- Robot explorer
- Ebola
- Addicted to energy
- Barn fire
- In the limelight
- One of our scientists is missing
- Think big
- Electronic patient records
- Grow your own body
- Ban cola?
- Attack of the giant viruses
- Car wars
- Eat insects
- Appliance science
- Chocolate money
- Big bag ban
- GM decisions
- Text neck
- Invasion!
- Life on Enceladus?